Canadians outraged by immigration raid staged for the cameras

Diana ThompsonBy Alan Bean

Canadian activists are outraged by an immigration raid in Vancouver that they claim was staged for a reality show.  The folks with the cameras claim they are producing a documentary and only use footage after getting verbal permission.  A woman working across the street from the action claims to be deeply upset: “It doesn’t seem very Canadian,” she told the Canadian Broadcast Corporation (CBC) “It’s very sensationalized. I don’t like it. It’s just very creepy.”

This video is taken from the Vancouver Sun’s story on the raid.

http://www.vancouversun.com/entertainment/CBSA+raid+migrant+workers+complete+with+camera+crew+raises+concerns+Vancouver/8093462/story.html#ooid=huMzM3YTp5X9MjDEogQcyEYI834YBHGS

Canadians define themselves in opposition to the United States.  As Prime Minister Pierre Trudeau once explained to an American reporter, “Living next to you is in some ways like sleeping with an elephant . . .  one is affected by every twitch and grunt.”  When Canadians say something “isn’t very Canadian” we usually mean it is very American.

Canadians have just recently gained a passion for deporting undocumented aliens.  True, the number of people deported from Canada increased by 50% between 1999 and 2009, but we’re talking about an increase from 8,361 deportations per year to 12,732.

Contrast that with the 400,000 folks the Obama administration deported last year.

Of course Canada is one-tenth the size of the US and doesn’t share a border with a less wealthy nation, so comparisons are precarious.  Still, I find the reaction of the populace gratifying.  People were generally outraged by the idea of staging an immigration sweep for the cameras, something that would hardly raise an eyebrow in the USA.  And the immigration people were quick to insist that they were really looking for a genuine baddie and just stumbled over the other people by accident.

Stephen Harper, the Canadian Prime Minister, appears to be fascinated by all things American, including our war on drugs and our prison industrial complex.  Is he now taking an interest in mass deportation?  Will private detention centers soon be springing up along the border between British Columbia and Washington State?  Perhaps some of our Canadian readers can shed some light on these questions.

Reality show filmed immigration raids, B.C. advocates say

CBC News

Posted: Mar 14, 2013

Immigration activists in Vancouver are protesting the arrest of eight migrant workers who they say were picked up by border agents and filmed for a reality TV series during a raid on a construction site on Wednesday.

Construction worker Gord Beck says he was working on a condo complex at Victoria Drive and 20th Avenue when armed border agents arrived in black SUVs.

Beck says they stationed officers at corners to keep people from running, and swept the site, top to bottom looking for undocumented workers.

“I’ve worked with a lot of guys with ankle bracelets and stuff, but I’ve never seen Immigration swamp a site like that,” Beck told CBC News.

Oscar Mata, who is originally from Mexico, was found hiding in a closet at the construction site by border officials.

“I go out and ask ‘why is the camera? He said ‘Oh don’t worry, is a reality show,’” Mata told CBC News.

Mata came to Canada five years ago. But when his student visa expired, Mata says he stayed illegally. He had been working at the site for the last three months.

Mindy Shepard, who was working across the street at the time, said she was shocked to see TV cameras recording up to a dozen arrests.

“It doesn’t seem very Canadian. It’s very sensationalized. I don’t like it. It’s just very creepy,” said Shepard.

The immigrant advocacy group No One Is Illegal says there were at least three such raids in the region on Wednesday and some of those arrested were asked to sign release forms so they could be identified for the reality TV program.

On Thursday, the Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA) declined CBC’s request for an on-camera interview.

In a written statement, a spokeswoman said officers conducted just one raid on Wednesday and had visited the construction site to locate a previously deported person with a long criminal history. The detained men were found by chance, the spokeswoman said.

“CBSA has a responsibility to protect the safety and security of Canadians by locating, arresting and removing individuals who pose a threat to public safety, who are subject to an outstanding immigration arrest warrant and who are in violation of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act, such as working without authorization,” the statement read.

Construction workers at this site in East Vancouver say it was raided by immigration agents on Thursday. Construction workers at this site in East Vancouver say it was raided by immigration agents on Thursday. (Steve Lus/CBC)

The CBSA also said that participation in the television series is strictly voluntary.

“An individual’s case will not be negatively or positively impacted by their decision to participate or not,” the statement read.

Documentary vs. reality series

According to the show’s website, Border Security: Canada’s Front Line is produced by Shaw Media in Vancouver and shadows CBSA officers working at air, land, and marine crossings in B.C.’s Lower Mainland and Vancouver Island.

The show is broadcast on the National Geographic Channel and is produced by Vancouver-based Force Four Entertainment.

On Thursday afternoon, Force Four Entertainment spokesman Andrew Poon issued a written statement, calling the show a “documentary series.”

“Yesterday’s events occurred as we were documenting the day-to-day activities of the CBSA’s inland enforcement team and were in no way planned or staged,” Poon wrote.

“We would not sensationalize any situation for this series. Border Security is a documentary, not a reality series.”

Poon said no one will be identified in the programs without their written permission and even with consent, their names will not be revealed.

Poon also said that “no one is filmed without their advance verbal permission.”

Protesters call filmed raids ‘dehumanizing’

A scene from Border Security: Canada's Front Line, a show on the National Geographic Channel. A scene from Border Security: Canada’s Front Line, a show on the National Geographic Channel. (National Geographic Channel)

On Thursday, a group of protesters held a noon-hour rally outside the federal immigration office in downtown Vancouver to call for an end to the filming of the TV show featuring border agents and an end to “intimidation raids at construction sites.”

Diana Thompson, the wife of a Honduran worker who was detained, said her husband was asked to sign a release form for his consent to be filmed but he refused.

“Disgusted,” Thompson said, choking back tears. “It’s already a horrible situation … and I feel that they make the matter even worse.”

Organizer Harsha Walia called the raids intimidation tactics that have no place in Canada.

“The fact that watching people being detained and arrested and humiliated and interrogated becomes something that we consume as part of our nightly entertainment – there is something deeply troubling about this and very dehumanizing.”

2 thoughts on “Canadians outraged by immigration raid staged for the cameras

  1. I’ve watched most, if not all of the episodes of “Border Security” on the National Geographic Channel, for the past 3 seasons, about the Canadian Border Security Agency and its front-line operations. There is one time I can recall enforcement agents apprehending a person who was within Canada, and that was done anonymously. It’s set at land and sea border crossings in BC, the main Post Office in Vancouver, Vancouver International Airport, etc.
    It is a law enforcement show, but there is a lot less handcuffing, and a lot more talking than you get on “Cops”. There would always be some implied encouragement to sign any consent to appear on camera, but the camera crew has got to get a signed release from everyone who appears on camera.

    Whether Prime Minister Harper is able to get a system of private federal detention centres for immigration violators or not, it seems that it is the kind of thing that is likely to appeal to his wing of the Conservative Party of Canada. He does like to look like he’s tough on those “terrorists” and the “illegal immigrants”,

    http://www.thestar.com/news/canada/2011/02/21/harper_tours_migrant_ship_vows_crackdown_on_human_smuggling.html

    but I guess it would depend on how long and successfully he gets to keep his powerbase in Parliament.

  2. Sounds like much ado about nothing. I immigrated to Canada 12 years ago and there are way too many migrants floating into Vancouver. Liberals always dismiss it because they’re afraid of being called racists (and so are most whites ironically), so it’s up to minorities like me to tell them to toughen up.

Comments are closed.