Evangelicals call for truce in the culture war

Samuel Rodriguez
Rev. Samuel Rodriguez

By Alan Bean

The basic thrust of the Imago Dei Campaign will not come close to satisfying liberals, but it is an excellent beginning.

It is frequently assumed that when Pope Francis talks about God’s love for gays, atheists and other traditionally demonized demographics, he is backing away from traditional Catholic teaching.  Not so.  Whatever his personal views may be, Pope Francis must hue to the established party line.  That’s what popes do.

In Francis we see a pronounced shift in tone and emphasis.  Hard line liberals aren’t impressed.  After all, they say, Francis still believes that homosexuality does not reflect the creative intention of God, and he affirms his church’s absolute opposition to abortion under any circumstances.  So why is everybody so excited?

We’re excited because the world’s most prominent religionist is publicly celebrating God’s love for all humanity.  God loves everybody, all the time, no matter what.  That’s what a shift in tone and emphasis looks like.

Similarly, Sammy Rodriguez, evangelists like James Robison, and the good folks at Focus on the Family can’t back away from their established positions on gay rights and abortion.  To do so would instantly end careers and destroy the prominent institutions these men are associated with.

But they have done what people in their position can do.  They have acknowledged the humanity of their ideological opponents.   They have admitted that every person on every side of our futile culture war debate is a child of God and thus worthy of respect.

We can’t have a conversation until these affirmations are made by people of good will on both sides of the cultural and religious divide.

Rev. Rodriguez, the official voice of Imago Dei (Image of God), is right about one thing; young people, conservative and liberal, have had enough of the culture war.

The Imago Dei Campaign: Evangelical Groups Say Gays Made in God’s Image

By Elizabeth Dias @elizabethjdias

Jan. 20, 2014

Gays are created in the image of God. So are liberals. The rich. The undocumented. Unbelievers. Everyone, even, and most importantly, the people with whom you do not agree.

That’s the message of the Imago Dei Campaign, a new movement of prominent evangelical groups launched on Monday to erode the culture war battle lines that have helped define evangelical discourse for the better part of half a century. The Imago Dei, or Image of God, pledge is simple: “I recognize that every human being, in and out of the womb, carries the image of God; without exception. Therefore, I will treat everyone with love and respect.”

Recognizing that every human is made in God’s image may seem like an easy statement for evangelicals to agree on, but the contemporary political implications are deep. The campaign takes pains to clarify what “every human being” really means—“For the image of God exists in all human beings: black and white; rich and poor; straight and gay; conservative and liberal; victim and perpetrator; citizen and undocumented; believer and unbeliever.”

The leader behind the movement, Rev. Samuel Rodriguez Jr., president of the National Hispanic Christian Leadership Conference, says the goal is to change the narrative of evangelical engagement in the public square, especially when it comes to traditional culture war issues. Other heavy hitters have joined him. President of Focus on the Family Jim Daly, televangelist James Robison, producer of The Bible Series Roma Downey and her husband, Survivor producer Mark Burnett, and vice president of the Liberty University Mat Staver have all signed on. The launch of the website was pegged to Martin Luther King Day as a reminder that the Biblical message and justice go hand in hand.

The Imago Dei signers are not making a political statement about hot-button issues like gay marriage. But the Imago Dei campaign does mark the first time, Daly says, that Focus on the Family—a group that opposes gay marriage—has publically stated that gays are created in God’s image alongside straight individuals. “People have said love the sinner, hate the sin,” Daly explains. “So often I think that has fallen woefully short, and it certainly appears like we are hating the sinner as well as the sin. And that is the difference—you’ve got to recalibrate and say I know you are made in God’s image, and therefore you deserve my respect.”

That change in tone is significant for organizations that have used the image of God doctrine to defend their opposition to gay marriage. A position paper still posted on the Focus on the Family website says: “Focus on the Family is dedicated to defending the honor, dignity and value of the two sexes as created in God’s image—intentionally male and female—each bringing unique and complementary qualities to sexuality and relationships.” When asked whether or not that position page would change given the Imago Dei Campaign, Daly did not say, but he clarified that affirming the image of God in people does not condone their behavior.

Rodriguez says that too often evangelicals in the United States have become known for what they oppose, and not for what they propose, and younger generations have had enough. “The church of Jesus Christ and the word hatred should not even appear in the same sentence,” Rodriguez says. “What if every single person can recognize the image of God in the other? Wouldn’t that bring down the noise of the hateful rhetoric? Wouldn’t that build a firewall between intolerance and bullying? Wouldn’t that build a firewall against extremism?”

It’s a fresh take on an old spiritual principle. The image of God doctrine, or imago dei doctrine as it is called in theological circles, has been central to Judeo-Christian faith from the beginning, and theologians long used Bible passages to explain the core dignity all people share. It comes first from the Genesis creation story, which says that humanity is made in the image of God: “So God created humankind in his image, in the image of God he created them; male and female he created them.” The Apostle Paul picked up on the idea in the New Testament, calling Jesus the “image of the invisible God, firstborn of all creation.”

The inclusion of the “straight and gay” clause is particularly bold given the heated political climate over gay marriage in the evangelical community, and that is precisely the point. Rodriguez, Daly and others hope that the Imago Dei message sets a new tone for evangelical conversations about controversial political topics. “We have broken this down into simply battle language, culture war, and I think it is frankly unhealthy,” Daly explains. “We need to express the Christian message in a different way.”

The Imago Dei may not go far enough for activists who want evangelical groups like Focus on the Family to completely reverse their position on gay marriage. But it is a step reminiscent of Pope Francis’ now historic “Who am I to judge” tone-shift on the gay community. Rodriguez hopes the Imago Dei will take hold with similar weight. “Can we go beyond having a confrontation, can we have a conversation that is better than a debate?” he asks. “We are coming into the room as equals because we are both made in the image of God. It changes everything.”


One thought on “Evangelicals call for truce in the culture war

Comments are closed.